What would make the claim seem questionable is the fact that Abigail was fired from the Proctors' house which was a family with a good reputation in society.
We can arrive at this answer because:
Abigail's firing was an issue that resonated a lot in the city and that was negative for her name, for that reason, her reputation can be questioned.
More information about "The Crucible" at the link:
https://brainly.com/question/7135046